Impaired neural development. Impaired language development and memory. Impaired ability to escape poverty for the rest of the child's life. These are the effects that neuroscientists have found in many children growing up in very poor families with low social status. These scientists claim these children have high levels of...no, not lead, they have high levels of "stress hormones."
These are indeed the findings presented recently at the American Association for the Advancement of Science. Stress hormones are associated with poverty, they claim, and these stress hormones permanently trap these children into lifetime poverty.
But if research shows that very much the same effects result from elevated blood lead levels in children, which is it that is causing the effect: lead or stress?
The scientists who claim it is lead also claim that they have made sure in their research to eliminate "confounding" factors, that is, other causes of the observed effects. But they missed this one, apparently. Maybe stress leads to lifetime poverty and elevated lead levels in poor children. Meanwhile, the scientists who are focusing on stress hormones may be forgetting about lead as a confounding factor in
THEIR research. Maybe lead causes stress which causes impaired neural development and lifetime poverty.
Are the scientists telling us the truth? Or are they all mixed up and confused? We think the latter.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
There appear to me many associations that affect a child's health. And much finger pointing. Many stand to make money if their "theory" is adopted and enacted. Such as lead paint removal.
Recently the two stories in the press, one about Pharaceuticles in drinking water, and the chemical, including pills, cause of Gulf War Illness show two things, there are chemicals in our environemnt that can have serious impact on the health of some individuals,and that those causes are poorly understood due to the resistence to even consider them
see...
http://blog.wired.com/wiredscience/2008/03/goverment-chemi.html
http://tinyurl.com/2mj5sb
The main post has no link to the referenced story, and the follow up comment contains a link which doesn't work. So not sure why I should believe either of you.
Post a Comment